At Nina's we watched the fantastic Crumb, a documentary about the American comic artist Robert Crumb. Crumb, his two brothers, his ex's and current wife are open, honest and articulate which makes for an engaging film. Crumbs story however doesn't rely on talking heads and anecdotes (which are excellent) but on his comic strips and sketchbooks which take you on a journey through his waking life and subconscious sexual desires and fears. The film, although allowing for some criticism of Crumbs work, is an understanding portrait. It also dealt sensitively to Crumbs brothers who have many 'issues' which could easily have been dramatised. We watched this as part of a double bill with a recently commissioned Britdoc film Here's Johnny about a graphic artist struggling against Multiple Sclerosis. It did have potential to be good, he is a good artists and the subject matter was interesting but it was really disappointing. There was no intimacy in the film and the heavy use of graphics didn't help. There was an honesty to much of what Johnny talks about but seemed mostly that kind of pub/jokey cynical truth that leaves you a bit cold.
Posts
